How online dating changed how I think about marketing.
When I first tried online dating, I did what most people do.
I found the best photos of myself, polished the profile and tried to make myself appealing to as many women as possible.
And it worked.
I got lots of dates.
They were fun, but they weren’t really going anywhere.
Eventually I realised I was optimising for the wrong thing.
I didn’t want to fill every spare night with a date.
I wanted to find my girl.
So I changed the approach.
First, I got really clear about the type of woman I actually wanted to meet.
I even wrote things like:
“I want a woman who’ll kick her shoes off and get sweaty on the dance floor, rather than stand at the side worrying her mascara might run.”
That would hopefully put off some of the women who weren’t right for me.
Then I went even further.
I stopped trying to make myself appealing to everyone.
I swapped my very best photos for fairly average ones.
And I added comments I’d heard on previous dates, things like:
“I thought he’d be taller.”
And:
“It was going OK until he accidentally set the restaurant menu on fire.”
The point was simple.
If being short or slightly clumsy was going to put someone off, I’d rather they knew before we wasted an evening finding out.
And yes, I got fewer dates.
A lot fewer.
But the second woman I dated after changing the profile became my wife.
And that changed how I think about marketing.
Businesses are often terrified of narrowing their audience because of FOMO.
We want the biggest possible market.
So we broaden the proposition, make the messaging safer and try to appeal to everyone who could buy.
But that often makes it harder for the people who are actually right for us to recognise themselves.
And we waste huge amounts of time and money chasing people who were never going to buy anyway.
A good ICP doesn’t just tell you who to target.
It helps you decide who not to target.
Because the goal isn’t to appeal to everyone.
It’s to make it really obvious to your people that you’re for them.
If your business is trying to appeal to everyone, book a free 30-minute call and tell me what's going on.
